This non-traditional Lemon Meringue Pie boasts a crispy, buttery crust. A lemony filling that sets up confidently. And a simple, fool-proof meringue that pairs perfectly with the filling. Best of all, it can (and should) be made ahead of time. It’s best this way. You’ll want to make sure you have a couple special tools for this pie: 10-inch removable bottom tart pan with a 2-inch height, Pastry Torch, Butane Fuel, and 2 lb. of pie weights
- 1/2 c. + 2 tbsp. all-purpose unbleached flour
- 1 tsp. sugar
- 1/4 tsp. kosher salt
- 6 tbsp. unsalted butter, cold
- 1/4 c. cold water
- 6 large egg yolks (save 2 whites for the meringue)
- 1/2 c. lemon juice (about 3 lemons, save zest for the meringue)
- 1 1/2 c. water
- 1 c. sugar (see notes)
- 1/4 c. organic cornstarch
- 1/4 tsp. kosher salt
- 2 tbsp. unsalted butter
- 1 1/2 c. sugar
- 1/3 c. water
- 2 large egg whites (reserved from filling)
- 1/4 tsp. cream of tartar
- 1/4 tsp. kosher salt
- zest from 1 lemon (optional)
Make the crust 1 day in advance. In a medium bowl, whisk together the flour, sugar, and salt. Cut the butter into skinny shreds (as if you were cutting thin slices of cheese) and toss them into the flour mixture to coat. Using your hands, quickly incorporate the butter into the flour until the butter resembles pea-sized crumbles. Pour in half the ice-cold water. Use a large fork to bring the dough together. Continue adding water until dough holds together. Form into a rough rectangle.
On a lightly floured surface, roll or press the dough out into a rectangle (about 6 x 4-inches). Cut the dough in half and stack, adding any random pieces in between. Press out again and repeat 3 more times. Wrap the dough in plastic wrap and place in the freezer for 20 minutes.
On a lightly floured surface, roll dough out to 13 1/2-inches in diameter. (The crust will be on the thinner side. This is important for maintaining a sturdy crust that wont soften after the filling is added.) Fold in quarters and place in a 10-inch removable bottom tart pan with a 2-inch height. (I’m a believer that all pie should be made in a removable bottom tart pan for easy slicing. Or, they need to start making removable bottom pie tins.) Unfold and center within the pan. Trim excess. Place pan in the freezer to chill for 10 minutes.
Meanwhile, preheat oven to 425°F. Before baking, prick the bottom and sides of the dough with a fork to keep from bubbling. Line with parchment paper and fill with pie weights. (Pie weights are sold in too small of quantities in my opinion. Buy two bags of them for adequate amounts.) Place pan on baking sheet and bake for 15 minutes. Remove the parchment and pie weights, and bake for 4 minutes more to allow the bottom to finish cooking. Set aside at room temperature. It’s normal for the crust to shrink a bit. This can be made a day in advance and stored uncovered.
Make the lemon filling at least 5 hours in advance. Juice the lemons and set aside. If you decide to use the optional zest into the meringue, zest one lemon first before juicing, and store covered. (The lemon zest helps to even out the sweetness of the meringue and carry the tartness throughout.) Separate the yolks and set aside, reserving 2 whites for the meringue. (Note: cold eggs are easier to separate than room temperature eggs. Make sure no yolk (fat) gets into the egg whites as this will inhibit a proper meringue from forming.)
In a medium saucepan, add the water, sugar, cornstarch, and salt. Whisk to combine. Bring to a simmer over medium-high heat whisking continually once it begins to thicken. Cook mixture until it becomes thick, translucent, and bubbly. Turn off heat.
Temper the egg yolks by pouring about 1/4 cup of the cornstarch mixture into the yolks, whisking continually to keep the eggs from curdling. Turn the heat back on the cornstarch mixture, and slowly pour in the egg yolks, whisking continually. Once incorporated, whisk in the lemon juice. Bring filling to a simmer. Once large lava bubbles appear on the surface, cook for 1 minute more to ensure a proper set. Remove from heat and stir in the butter until incorporated. Place a fine mesh sieve in the bowl of the crust. Pour the filling through the sieve to catch any larger, unwanted bits. Immediately cover the filling surface with plastic wrap, and place in the fridge to cool for 2 hours.
Make the meringue at least 3 hours before serving and once the filling has chilled for two hours. In a medium saucepan add about 2 inches of water and bring to a boil. Place a metal bowl (not glass) on top and check to make sure the water doesn’t touch the bottom of bowl.
Remove the bowl and add all the meringue ingredients except for the zest. Using a handheld mixer, mix for 30 seconds to incorporate. Once the water comes to a boil, place the bowl over the saucepan and begin beating immediately on high speed. Set the timer for 7 minutes and continually beat. Mixture will begin to thicken around the 3 minute mark. After 7 minutes, remove the bowl to the counter and continue beating until sturdy enough to hold stiff peaks. Add the zest and mix again until just incorporated.
Remove the pie from the fridge. Discard plastic wrap and add meringue on top of the filling. Using the back of a spoon, pull swoops and circles to create an organic pattern. Using a pastry torch, torch the top until golden. You can also place it directly under a broiler keeping very close watch. You wont have as much control this way. Lightly tent foil so that it’s not touching the meringue and refrigerate for at least 3 hours or overnight. Pie is best served within 2 days.
To serve the pie, pop it out of the tart pan. Heat a sharp knife by running it under hot water first and wiping dry. Slowly saw to cut the pie. Rinse knife, heat, and dry before each cut. Pie is best served chilled. To save the cut pie, place a piece of plastic wrap on the exposed cut.
• The lemon filling can be made with 3/4 cup sugar while still setting up nicely. Sugar helps the filling (and meringue) to set up. If you remove too much of it, you may end up with a soupy pie. It’s also worth noting that lemons vary in tartness. Meyer lemons are almost sweet and could use less sugar.
Thank you for this recipe. It was my first time making Lemon Meringue Pie and it was perfect. I was anxious because I making it the night before a holiday and it was the only dessert I was serving. No pressure! I tripled the meringue because I wanted to use up the egg whites. I topped the pie then made Meringue cookies with the left over meringue. The cookies were a hit too!
Do you have any recommendations for how to scale for a pie pan? I’m working on a smaller grad school kitchen. Thanks!
Hi Elise! I haven’t done the math. But I’d recommend comparing the volume of your pan to the volume of the tart pan. Let me know what you find!
Okay this is so #nationalpieday . I’m obsessed, great recipe and your photography is striking!
chilling the pie sounds like a wonderful idea, because it always feels a tad too sweet for me anyways. thanks for sharing Melissa! it’s huge to make something someone else has done for so long but I think it’s the ultimate compliment as well. Is there a sweeter way to remember someone? 🙂
(I think you have a little typo in “Once the water comes to a bowl”, I believe you meant “boil”)
Thanks for the catch! Updating now.
Bravo for all of your hard work on this one, Melissa! I loved reading the story of this pie (and seeing it on your Instagram stories!). 🙂 I’m going to bookmark this recipe to make for Reuben as a special treat sometime.
Thanks Erica! This one almost did me in. I hope you guys like it if/when you try it!
I have a love/hate relationship with lemon meringue pie. As in I love to eat it, but I hate to make it! You’re so right that a good lemon meringue pie recipe could never fit onto a 3×5 recipe card, and you’re very brave for taking on the responsibility of keeping this pie tradition alive in your husband’s family! Your recipe sounds incredible, and I’m definitely going to give it a try!
Brave is right. I almost begged someone else to take on this role, until I landed on this recipe!
What a fantastic looking pie! I can never get meringue to look like that.
I’m totally with you. This particular meringue is way easier to work with!
I adore the story behind this pie Mel! I think Margaret would be proud, what a lovely pie. xo
Thank you, Abby ❤️
Looks incredible! Can’t wait to try it out.
This pie is my nemesis. I’ve made it twice using the America’s Test Kitchen recipe. I’ve got the crust and meringue nailed but the filling, oh the filling. First time, absolute soup. Tasty but soup. Second time, slightly thicker soup. Three strikes and I’m out so I’ve been stalling on what may be my final attempt. I will have to compare your filling recipe to the one that was in the ATK cookbook. Maybe they goofed? More likely, it’s just me.
This pie! I feel you. I hope this one works for you! I’ve found that the 1 final minute of cooking with lava bubbles on the surface ensures a proper set! Also, a chill in the fridge helps that process. We found that we actually liked the pie better chilled over Thanksgiving, which also helps to keep everything in place. So I developed this recipe to stay cozy in the fridge.
I agree. Letting the pie cool for at least 2 hours at room temperature, then popping it in the fridge for about 2 or 3 hours prior to serving, will help set and firm up the pie. And the meringue ,if it was cooked on top of the stove with the sugar dissolved inside the egg white for about 4 minutes and whipped on high speed with some vanilla extract and cream of tartar to stiff peaks. And add a cornstarch and water mixture that is cooked over medium heat till it thickens and cools and add it to the meringue when it holds stiff peaks. Spread the meringue evenly over the hot filling. Place it under the broiler for 1-2 minutes or bake on the next to the highest rack under the broiler on 350°F for 10-12 minutes.